Uncivilisation

Sid Meier's Civilization IV

Sid Meier’s Civilization IV

A propos of nothing at all to do with this blog, here’s my version of the computer game, Civilization IV. I’ve subverted its goal though: not to build the “best” empire, but to be as uncivilised or anarchic as possible. This may suggest how to survive the worst aspects of empire, such as power, slavery, poverty, disease and so on. Of course this is just a game and its rules don’t reflect the real world, or even this society’s interpretation of it, so the exercise is simplistic.

The first over-simplification is the picking of a country to play, the assumption being that countries, or states, are the only logical starting point for humanity beyond tribalism. Still, this makes it clear that expansive or aggressive states are a big threat and the only apparent counter to them is hostility. Try reading a book or saying a prayer in the face of a steel blade.

So, it’s gratifying that Mongolia and Genghis Khan (as leader, so not very anarchist) are a logical choice for aggression, with expansion for good measure. We’re not trying to be expansive, quite the reverse: we just want to survive the expansion of others. Fight fire with fire, and offence is the best form of defence, and so on.

Although culture may be an artefact of civilisation, the game rules force one into adopting it. There’s a weird correlation between it and how far from a city one can access resources, which is certainly not real. One would almost imagine that culture really equates to territory or land base.

No matter how barbarian we want to be, resources within a territory are vital. We starve and can’t make weapons for our defence otherwise. In game terms resources, and hence culture, are crucial.

The odd obelisk and library help here but far better is to plump for Genghis’ grandson, Kublai, as leader instead. He generates culture in each city, and I suppose that is one desirable by-product of society. (You could also argue for science despite its unfortunate role in subjecting citizens to control and subordination.)

So, Kublai Kahn gives much better access to resources, essential of which for Mongolia is the horse. Without horses the Mongolians can’t build keshiks, their specialist military unit and a huge advantage at the beginning of the game. Don’t forget: we’ve decided that fighting is our best route to success. So, we need to throw away any games where horses are not available.

More generally we must still place cities in resource-rich locations. This implies a degree of luck in the game’s starting conditions but that’s always so. Indeed, it also reflects the role that luck played in blessing early civilisations with a head start over their neighbours. Our anarchists will require good fortune to stay independent.

The need for horses gives a clear technological strategy too. Hunting (a given for the Mongols), archery, husbandry and riding are a must. Of these, archery is always good for defence anyway and paves the way for longbowmen; with two promotions they provide the strongest city defence for a good stretch of the game. Mining, bronze and iron working, with associated resources, will be necessary for other armed units. Fishing and sailing too to defend our seas.

To exploit resources we’ll need the calendar and agriculture. It is odd though that the latter needs to be invented after the founding of cities: it was demonstrably the other way round. Also odd that we need monarchy to develop wineries if grapes happen to be on our patch. Another useful early technology is meditation, which leads to monasteries with their cultural boost.

Cities should generally build troops but for this reason barracks are obviously a good choice as an improvement. They give new troops extra experience, which is good for an automatic promotion. Otherwise, improvements should be at an ideological minimum, except the aforementioned libraries will allow scientists and hence more military technology.

Of course gold is also handy for research, which should be kept high. This is a good spot at which to note that many military units can drain the treasury and here’s the essence of the campaign: these units must expect to die regularly in harrying neighbouring civilisations. Beware war weariness though: there will have to be intervals of peace.

Under our strategy granaries will be an early option but they seem to be ineffective. Later, when cities have grown, the extra health delivered by them may come in. Walls are a military defence but only for front-line cities; if we’ve reached the stage of needing them elsewhere, we’ve probably lost already. One or two workers are always a good idea but what about settlers?

The strategic placement of new cities could stop others’ expansion. Sheer population pressure may also force the odd settler and, of course, the need for resources.

The next post will expand on that and much else.

If you wish to register, please email me
Log in

Archives

Expand All
BUBO Listing www.bubo.org
  • Categories


  • My Favourite Links

  • Ross’s Gull, Topsham

    Ross's Gull

    Ross’s Gull, Manitoba © Dominic Sherony

    Or RSPB Bowling Green Marsh, to give its full and accurate name, but that makes rather a long title. The reserve is just south of Exeter, and thus in Devon, on the east of the Exe Estuary. It’s an easy run from Bristol but I motored from Porlock, of which more later, over Exmoor and all the way down the valley of the Exe. That’s a pretty run, far prettier than the M5, if a touch slower.

    Parking at the site was difficult, probably because of more…

    Black-Winged Stilt, Meare Heath

    Mystery Moth

    Mystery Moth, South Downs

    My 154th species for the year and one that I’ve not seen since the long-stayer at Titchwell in 2004. In this country that is: Barcelona and Malta have supplied sightings in the interim. Travels farther afield have also brought black-necked (USA) and white-headed (Australia).

    But the Somerset Levels bird was the European black-winged stilt and it hung around late Sunday evening, thank God. A crash at Wincanton on the A303 more…

    Cory’s Shearwaters, Tenerife

    Cory's Shearwater

    Cory’s Shearwater © Christine Veeschkens

    These seabirds were the principals of the final Tenerife show, in a way I couldn’t have expected and didn’t want. As my last evening fell, I was returning from the Guaza cliffs at one end of Los Cristianos. Above a cove a man and woman unloaded three boxes from a car and somehow I knew what was in them.

    The breathing holes would have been one clue. I lurked to watch more…

    Blogiversary Books

    The fifth year of this blog is probably worth a mention and I have a couple of outstanding book reviews, so they’ll do as a celebration. First up is Civilization by Niall Ferguson. It’s the sort of book that contains interesting and arresting nuggets.

    For instance, 70% of Iran’s science and engineering students are women. Written in about 2010, is this still true after four further years of Western sanctions and retrenchment? It is a point to illustrate the book’s central thesis that more…

    Migrants for the Year List

    Spring migration has predictably pushed my year list on to 144, compared with 150 last year but 2014 is so far purely an English tally. Yes, I’ve not even ventured into Wales, which may change tomorrow.

    This 144 was boosted mightily two weeks ago by stops at Selsey Bill and Pagham Harbour. Unexpected sanderlings there preceded rather late dates for more…

    Glaucous Gull, Blue Anchor

    Just one day after the glossy ibis, my Somerset list got back on level terms with Avon. Not only that, it contributed to my English list. Two juvenile glaucous gulls had been at this western extremity of the county for nearly a month, so it was time to go see. Especially as I’d only ever logged the species in Britain twice – at Peterhead and Arbroath, the latter seven years ago.

    The Blue Anchor birds were reported as distant at sea and I parked the scope and scanned the one flock of gulls I could find out there. No joy. I didn’t know more…

    Glossy Ibis, Weston STW

    Where STW stands for sewage treatment works. An acronym that birders know well but is more lost on the general public. After all, the latter don’t flock to such places for their leisure whereas the former know them as honeypots. (Oh, and Weston is Weston-super-Mare.)

    So the bird became my 193rd Avon species, which puts the county as numero uno British county above Somerset. I hadn’t realised that more…

    2014 Year List?

    Sneyd Park Cottage, Bristol

    Sneyd Park Cottage

    The big month in March has rather fizzled into an attempt at a big year in 2014. For which on the 22nd, local visits to Leigh Woods and Marshfield netted treecreeper (my first since 2012 though!), marsh tit, linnet and a solitary corn bunting. Slimbridge, a week later, added three cranes, five avocets and a flock of black-tailed godwits. Then a late afternoon shift over the Severn in the Forest of Dean gave me mandarin duck and a brief flash of a goshawk.

    Which made 112 for the year. Could that be a platform for attacking my record of more…

    Orkney, 1998

    I made a solid start to my biggest month of May 1998 with 40 species at Upton Warren. Devil’s Spittleful, an interesting sandy heath by Kidderminster, added 8 more before a return to Upton boosted the total to 60 in the first week.

    However, Scotland unlocked the bulk of the species. Yup, I went on holiday. In Angus, Auchmithie alone was good for another 20, with great birds like more…